Top 5

Bookish: Top 5 Wednesday – Magic Systems

magic systems


Although I will read anything my grubby hands can touch, my first love is fantasy and usually anything that contains magic 1 is what those grubby hands will reach for first.

Magical systems can be gloriously complex or surprisingly simple. Sometimes the magic system is well-thought and designed to the nth degree and sometimes its so flimsy that if you peered hard enough you would see it crumble like a cake.

There appears to be a need for rules.

In my own writing journey I have found that the following areas/ questions are often asked when an individual is considering creating a magic system within their world:-

  • What is magic used for?
  • Who can use it?
  • How can they use it?
  • Where is it from?
  • What are the limitations/ dangers/ costs?
  • How does magic fit into the overall culture of your world?

In my humble opinion a flimsy magic system can be just as fun as one that has taken years to build. Sometimes magic 1is fun simply because it happens to be magic 1and frankly that’s good enough for me!


jonathan strange.png


If you haven’t read Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell and you love magic systems and fictional alternative histories than I suggest you tackle this beast! And a beast it is at something like 1000+ pages.

At times it’s a little heavy with the world building but this has one of the most complicated (yet interesting) magic systems that accurately borrows aspects from fairy tale and folklore.

This is a ‘magic coming back into the world’ book and is a story about two magicians who have very different magical methods and their very different methods begin to cause some strife in their lives.

Mr. Norrell is a magical purist who considers himself a ‘learned’ magician on account of his magic books and spells but doesn’t really want to contribute to society via his magic in any way. This isn’t always a good thing. Jonathan Strange is younger, impulsive (and more unstable) magician who wants to explore what magic can do. This isn’t always a good thing either.

This book goes deep into its fictional historical routes of magic and delves into the other characters who either also use magic or have been impacted by it.




A Song of Ice and Fire is also another ‘magic is coming back’ book in a world where a rich magical heritage disappeared.

Why it disappeared is anyone’s guess and how it came back (and why) is also anyone’s guess but it appears to be connected to the re-emergence of the White Walkers north of The Wall and the re-birth of dragons. I have questions:-

  1. Are the White Walkers and dragons back because magic is coming back?
  2. Did the White Walkers and dragons coming back cause the magic to return?
  3. Is the universe of Westeros a balanced force and because one half was returning, the other half also needed to return?

I mean we think that the dragons were born because of a need to stop the White Walkers but could it be that the White Walkers are re-emerging because they could sense the dragons were about to be born?!

George R.R. Martin will never answer these. I will never stop hoping he finishes the series.

I also enjoy the magic that is tied to the varying religions. For example Melisandre who follows a light and fire based god obtains her magic by…. burning people. And also you would not want to be her gynaecologist.


american gods

I want to include a Neil Gaiman on here and so I will go with American Gods.

The magic is performed by gods and they can do magic because they are gods. Some would say this means what they do falls under the remit of miracles but in honesty… not all they do is good.

The magic performed is dependent on the god and what their original purpose was. For example, Eostre (the pagan goddess of spring and fertility) is very good at doing spring like things including the awakening of life…

My very favourite thing about American Gods is the limits of the gods. Despite being gods they are extremely dependent on people as it is people’s belief’s that power’s them. No belief = no worship = no power = cessation of existence.

There is also another lady where you wouldn’t want to be her gynaecologist…




If I’m ever given a chance to include The Bartimaeus Trilogy on a blog post than I’ll take it because I’m not going to rest until more people have read these books.

Like Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell listed above these books are also based on fictional alternative histories where magic and magicians exist. The difference is this is set in modern times and is much more political in that magicians are also politicians and in power simply because they can use magic.

The story follows Nathaniel who is a talented but young magician as he begins his ascent to power, Kitty who is a commoner who despises magicians and is immune to magic and the sassiest character ever created – Bartimaeus. Bartimaeus is a djinni who exists in The Other Place.

This is the magician’s secret – they have the ability to summon djinni’s and enslave them but it is the djinni’s power that is the real magic.

Hijinks of most awesomeness ensue.




In Carnivale, hijinks most definitely do not ensue.

This is one of the few non-book examples that I will use but I really enjoyed Carnivale in all its gritty, depression era misery and the magic and mythology around it really interested me.

Carnivale is essentially a battle of good vs. evil all played out around a travelling carnival show. It didn’t last too long as a series which is a shame but if you like creepy – go and watch this.

In every generation there is always a person that is the avatar of light and another that is the avatar of darkness and whoever ‘wins’ ushers in the next period for mankind. Light doesn’t always win. As evidenced by the depression and First World War.

The great thing about the show was that in the first season you had both avatar’s but you weren’t too sure which one was which.

This has extensive (and often complex) world building and the mythology reaches back generations. The magic in this world is often linked to the avatars and the impact that they have on their environment and the people that travel with them.


So here are my five this week? What do you think? What are your favourites? Has anyone other than me watched Carnivale??

Until next time!



19 thoughts on “Bookish: Top 5 Wednesday – Magic Systems

    1. I’ve chosen some hefty reads/ shows to be fair! I’m a huge Neil Gaiman fan but he is odd so I would say *don’t* start with American Gods as a way to ease yourself in! It has a polarising effect of either drawing people in or putting people off! I love magic systems too and was glad they had this as an option!


  1. Ughh now I want to read Strange & Norrell again. 😀 That’s such a cool illustration of them! I love the magic system in that book, and it’s heavily underappreciated because people think long books = boring. :S I love the ASOIAF magic too, I’m mostly intrigued by children of the forest and sorcerers of Ashai though. 😀 I do love dragons! I’m thinking the white walkers woke up because of the long winter coming, and dragons were born as a contrast to that, and I think it all connects to some prophecy (I’m fond of prophecies), hope Martin will get the chance to explain all that. I love magic systems in Harry Potter, Tolkien’s books, Discworld (Which isn’t a system but a chaos more accurately), and I loved the one in Uprooted. 🙂 Oh also the one in Six of Crows! I’ll stop yammering. I’ll read The Bartimaeus Trilogy, promise. 🙂 I also always wanted to watch Carnivale!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I love the artwork that people do, I wish I could be that talented! I enjoyed Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell so much but I haven’t watched the tv yet so may do that instead of a re-read 😛 Lazy girl’s guide to life!

      ASOIAF has one of the best magic systems ever, it’s so thought out and interesting. I’m kind of hoping the dragons are the winners but I don’t think it would be a ‘win’ as such.

      I had so many more I could have gone with and I was thinking of Harry Potter, Discworld and Uprooted actually! It was hard to decide. I’ve not read Six of Crows yet but it’s very much on my list.

      Carnivale is good (first season is the best) but it is really creepy and dark at times – just to forewarn!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Me too, me too… :/ Haha, I loved the show so I approve that instead of a re-read! 😀

        Ahh me too, and I agree, as Martin said, the ending will be bitter-sweet and the show runners will stick to it. I cried my eyes out when Viserion died. 😦

        Hahaha I know, it’s kind of lame to use the same novels all the time, but they’re so good. 😀 Oooh can’t wait to hear your thoughts on SoC! 🙂

        Haha woman, I feed on creepy and dark, no warnings for me necessary. xD Hmm that would definitely make a good October watch!

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Oh god! Viserion! It was awful but part of me thought something like that would happen. I hope he’s re killed quickly because I don’t like seeing him like that 😢 Dany’s face broke me….

          Carnivale is a superb October watch! I’d love to know your thoughts on it as people go one of two ways!

          Liked by 1 person

          1. I really had no idea, so it hit me like a train. 😦 I hope that all dragons remain alive in the book version, and that an ice dragon appears in another way, it’s logical if Martin continues as he originally planned, hope he doesn’t get affected by the series. :/

            Woohoo, I’ll watch it then, as I’ve already binge-watched everything I could. 😀

            Liked by 1 person

            1. I think it was such a massive thing that it will happen in the book as well. In a series where he always talks about killing off those who don’t think will get killed off, it kind of makes sense. I’m also gutted about the deaths of the dire wolves and I don’t think Summer’s was really dwelled on like it should have been especially because of the link she shared with Bran. But then it symbolised that summer was gone, winter had come and Bran as he was was no more.

              I binge watched Jonathan Strange this weekend! Loved it!!!!

              Liked by 1 person

                1. I’m waiting for more Nymeria!

                  Oh yes! I love Marc Warren though, he does creepy so well! I think I preferred the series Arabella and Jonathan relationship and the book Stephen. In the series I didn’t really like what they did to his character. But Childermass though! Love him!!!!

                  Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s a book that has very decisive opinions for sure, personally I love it but I’ve seen that other people hate it with a passion. It is definitely very odd but for me that’s the appeal! Go into it with an open mind! I’d love to know what you think!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s